Fatcow Icon
20/20 visits Appalachia
by Chuck Owens
Feb 22, 2009 | 5072 views | 16 16 comments | 27 27 recommendations | email to a friend | print
ABC News' 20/20 and native Kentuckian Diane Sawyer just completed another ad nauseam addition of "Let's explore the unfortunate hill people, their sordid ancestry, and dental problems." Like most of the other documentaries since the early 1960's only a few things have changed. The hillbilly wooden shacks are replaced with dilapidated trailers, the junk cars are no longer just Fords and Chevys, but now include a few imported models, and the trashed plastic food containers scattered over grassless yards are printed with labels warning of high fat content.

One might ask when the last expose' will be filmed, edited, and shown about our homeland. It is always a good place to go for a story, so the answer is probably never. On the other hand, it is a good place to observe what socialism, in the name of government assistance, has done to a once proud people.

One trillion dollars did not end poverty in the mountains. Lyndon Johnson's War on Poverty began to funnel money into the mountains, unfortunately, with only little impact. The poverty rate changed from around thirty eight percent in 1964 to thirty percent today. Not much to show for a trillion bucks.

The afflicted mountain people shown on 20/20 exist in a state of misery. Miserable people often take drugs or drink alcohol. Mother's Little Helper, a legendary drug song by the Rolling Stones, wasn't written about backwoods hillbillies. No, it was for the woman of the 1960's who had it all except for peace and tranquility. When you narrow it down, that is what most humans want from this life; just a little peace and tranquility in a sea of problems and turmoil that we more often than not find no comfort in.

Never excuse the lawbreakers though. Never give them the benefit of the doubt concerning their miserable existence in this most notorious of brevities, or try to find out why they consistently dole out scarce resources needed for food, rent, and clothing for their kids just to find tranquility from a chemical laden capsule. Stick them in jail forever, and endless rehab; separate them from the families that need them. Punish them forever for trying to escape despair; protect them from themselves with punishment.

The fact remains that unless one is born into the system that perpetuates such misery, seeing it, hearing it, and smelling it doesn't allow anyone to think they somehow know the plight of the desperately poor. Government failed. Endless orisons never seem to reach high enough out of the dark hollows even for those who remain faithful despite the trials. Education is not treasured, and real work is only for those who live where it can be found. Junk collectors and moss gatherers permeate the trash littered hillsides while the self-righteous, middle class multitudes ring out with, "Just go out and get a job!"

The saddest thing of all is that the people who suffer and are stuck in these mountains are a victim of what many around here don't like to discuss, even though it is so true. "The swirling eddy of hopelessness" in our Appalachian mountains is notorious and seemingly forever. It is easier to blame it on shiftless, lazy, ancestrally challenged people than to consider there may still be a solution to the problem. Poverty doesn't have to be forever.

There is a way to end this problem but government can't do it by tossing subsistence money allocations to the unfortunate like one might toss bread crumbs to a hungry carp. Politicians have visited many times, have tried, and failed. There is not enough charity to end it, even if charity was the answer.

The free market system is the answer. If businesses move into Kentucky's little corner of Appalachia, much of this nonsense called poverty would disappear. Those children who were interviewed on 20/20 were, for the most part, just as intelligent as anyone in this country. The only things that gave them away were their dialect and the history of poverty they experienced and then retold. Remove them from the "The swirling eddy of hopelessness" and the sky would be the limit for them. Remove them from a society that doesn't know a good paying job and the eddy's gentle, but deadly swirl would turn into a rushing stream of capitalistic endeavor and prosperity. Target the kids for positive change at school. Sadly, the adults may be beyond help; just another lost generation unless convinced there is indeed a world, worthy of living in without the crutch of drugs.

Failed governmental systems mysteriously arise from political graveyards in times of crisis. Socialism survives somehow and thrives, hovering just below the political visual threshold of many Americans who in fact do not even have a clue what it means. Consider the failures our government created in Appalachia as evidenced by the 20/20 report, but more importantly from all the other indicators of poverty that statistics provide. Spreading the wealth is a recipe for failure and a roadmap to dependence.

America did not achieve the highest standard of living in the world by depending on government for its every need. Individual entrepreneurs who took risks to establish a business and then hired people to share in the wealth made us the only place on earth where people would risk death to come to. Instead of dumping more money into the Appalachian welfare sink hole, why not provide incentives to the private sector by lowering taxes and giving them monetary and other incentives to locate here, prepare children to do the work early on, and then hire the younger generation just as they graduate from high school.

A trillion dollars in welfare didn't change things very much. Forty five years of bailouts failed. Generations continue to be born and will die in some the worst poverty stricken areas of this nation. It would be a great day in Appalachia if only our poor neighbors one day could experience an occasional recession as we are now in instead of living in one their entire lives.

Chuck Owens is department chairperson of social studies at Middlesboro High School.
Comments
(16)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
dora
|
April 07, 2009
Anyone interested in this program should read the article in The Corbin Times on Feb. 23, 2009 by Samantha Swindler. Ms. Swindler is insightful and right on the mark in this article. Helped my thinking a lot. If you are not familiar with her writing, I suggest you look at it particularly this article about this subject.
RollingMyEyes
|
March 20, 2009
I agree, great article Chuck...you are right on the mark!
obo1983
|
February 28, 2009
FRIST OF ALL EVERY THING HE WROTE IS TRUE.A LOT OFF PEOPLE DON'T WANT THE TRUTH.THATS WHY THIS COUNTRY IS IN THE SHAPE IT'S IN TODAY.I GREW UP IN A GOOD HOME.MY DAD WORKED THREE JOBS.HE TAUGHT US TO WORK.BUT SOME PEOPLE DON'T HAVE THAT CHANCE,BECAUSE THE GOV,HAS KEPT THEM UP ALL THERE LIVES.OR SHOULD I SAY OUR TAX DOALLARS HAS.THIS WEEK MY WIFES COUSION DIED.HER DOCTOR LEFT.SO SHE RUN OUT OFF PILLS,SO THEY PUT HER IN A ROOM FOR A COUPLE OF DAYS.THEY TOLD HER SHE COULD GO HOME THAT THERE WAS NOTHING WRONG WITH HER.A FEW DAYS LATER HER 10YR OLD FOUND HER HANGING FROM HER CELLING.JUST LIKE HE SAID,THEY JUST PUSH YOU AWAY THEY DON'T WANT TOO FOOL WITH YOU.JUST LIKE SHE SAID IN HER LETTER SHE COULD NOT TAKE THE DEMONS NO MORE.YOU NO I'M PROUD OF THE MAN WHO WROTE THIS CAUSE HE IS MY BROTHER.AND MY OTHER BROTHER WOULD BE TOO.SOMEONE ASK,WHERE DID YOU GO,NO WHERE,,HIS JUST A HILLBILLY LIKE ME AND YOU.AND HE MADE IT
BlueRibbon
|
February 27, 2009
Dang!! We missed a great opportunity before Bush went out of office. We could have had one of our mayors threaten his daddy, and he would have declared war on appalachia, bombed the bejeebers out of us, then spent billions upon billions rebuilding our towns, schools, and infrastructure!! We could have spread rumors where the evil mayor was hiding so every county received their fair share of the bombs. Boy, did we blow it!! Then Diane Sawyer wouldn't have been able to get great Nielsen ratings by focusing on the worst of the worst we have to offer.
loved
|
February 27, 2009
I think if more of us would reach out and help our people...we would all feel and see such good resutls...so let's all help our people .most of these people wants there all famiels to help...not strangers....so let help our own..while we can...
mistifaye
|
February 26, 2009
wonderful write up just wonderful. I agree, and for those of you who are glad you got away...how many family members did you leave behind? im sure you still have family here dont forget about them and never forget where you came from, these people could have very well been you or me.
VICKH
|
February 26, 2009
SOME PEOPLE NEED FENCES PUT ON THEIR MOUTH YOU CAN'T DO THE TALK UNTILL YOU DO THE WALK

WE HAVE A LOT OF GOOD HARD WORKING PEOPLE HERE IN THE HILLS AS SOME CALL IT. BY THE GRACE OF GOD I WORKED MY WAY OUT OF THE HARD TIMES AND I OWN MY OWN HOME NOW AND LIVE COMFORTABLE.SOME PEOPLE JUST GET TIRED AND GIVE UP,ITS A HARD LIFE FOR A LOT OF THEM.BEING PUT DOWN ALL THE TIME IS NO WAY TO HELP PEOPLE THEY NEED HELP AND ENCOURAGEMENT. THE NEXT TIME YOU CUT INTO THAT BIG JUICY STEAK THANK GOD FOR IT. SOME OF THESE LITTLR KIDS HAVE NEVER HAD ONE.I LOVE MY BLUE KENTUCKY HILLS.
napier
|
February 25, 2009
Funny how it is all bad. I always read the comments of how it is horrible back home. Whether it is drugs, money, people's attitude and so on....I moved away from Arjay in 1986 when I joined the military. I've been back a few times visiting family and friends. And I can honestly say that I miss being there sometimes. I miss how simple life is and not rushed. Their have been very few of my friends that stayed home since they graduated. I guess you can't blame them really. Always something better somewhere else. At least that is how I looked at the simple life. But now that I am retiring this year I believe I might move back home and take it easy for awhile. Heck, I don't even know if I will fit in. I have lost the accent and I have all my teeth.
dora
|
February 25, 2009
Where did you go?
Eric_Shawn
|
February 25, 2009
They just need to put a big fence around South Eastern Ky to keep it from infesting the rest of the country. I am glad I moved far away from them "hill-people"!
dora
|
February 24, 2009
Successful program from the War on Poverty: Head Start Program... still thriving and helping children do better in school.

The G.I. Bill was a terrificly successful U.S. Government program for soldiers returning from World War II. The beautiful rock work done at Pine Mountain State Park was a government program during the Great Depression. Our United State Government has provided a lot of infrastructure, and social programs that have moved our country forward. Not every government program is successful. But not every private enterprise endeavor is successful either. So let us keep trying as a country to provide for those who cannot (the mentally ill, the handicapped, the physically ill) and provide programs to help those on drugs and training and education for the poor, provide a good financial system for conducting business. Good luck to us all.
9094
|
February 23, 2009
After watching Diane Sawyer's report on ABC news, I have a whole new respect for my parents. They left Frakes, Kentucky nearly fifty years ago! I owe everything I am and everything I have, to the hard decision they made. To leave their parents, brothers and sisters behind and go to Illinois wasn't an easy task. I can not imagine what it was like for them. I cried every time we visited and then had to say goodbye. It would have been easy to just pack our bags and move down there but.... it never was an option. Doing what was best for their child came first! That meant we were staying in Illinois, where my dad had a good job and I would have a great education. Thank goodness it wasn't me on ABC news! Thank you Mommy and Daddy.
dora
|
February 23, 2009
It was almost impossible for the children up the hollers to go to college (I am a Bell County coal miner's daughter) until Bobby Kennedy campaigned in Appalachia and saw the extreme poverty. For some reason I had always wanted to go to college, but it was a struggle to afford high school (proper clothes, supplies, etc.) so I had no idea how I would make it to college Bell County High School. Then the student loans started... I got grants, etc. I was not the only one, many of my peers were surprisingly able to attend college because of the War. Certainly the War on Poverty did not cure everything... just as the neglect of the poor does cure everything. There have been political reasons(including the lack of roads, education, etc.). businesses have not migrated to eastern KY. Education is more readily available now, but jobs are still lacking and the Republicans have been in charge for a long time. We need to quit being defensive and mount a respectful intelligent campaign to destroy the stereotypes.
BellBlogger
|
February 23, 2009
Great column and analysis!
TXcousin
|
February 22, 2009
Hey Chuck-One of your TX cousins thinks that you wrote a great article and agrees with you 100%. Keep up the good work!
VICKH
|
February 22, 2009
I THINK ITS ABOUT TIME SOMEONE TAKES NOTICE OF THE POOR PEOPLE IN THE MOUNTAINS I WORKED AT A LARGE RETAIL STORE I SAW THE POOR COME OUT ON THE FIRST AND 3 OF THE MONTH THE KIDS THOUGHT THEY WERE IN HEAVEN AND THEY HAVE TO WAIT ANOTHER WHOLE MONTH TO GO OUT AGAIN THE ONES GOING TO SCHOOL GET BREAKFAST AND LUNCH BUT WHAT ABOUT THE ONE THAT DON'T GO TO SCHOOL

WE NEED SOME GOVERMENT HELP BROUGHT IN THIS COUNTY BELL AND HARLAN SOME PEOPLE DON'T KNOW HOW LUCKY THEY ARE UNTILL THEY SEE ALL THE MISERY HERE WE WATCH IT ON TV ABOUT OTHER COUNTRYS BUT WHAT ABOUT US?
Weather
Sponsored By:

Lottery
Sponsored By:

Stocks
Sponsored By:

Gas Prices
Sponsored By:

Featured Businesses
Recipes
Sponsored By: